In 1978, a feud was born that is now very much apart of Rugby League folklore and history. In the pre-season of 1978, there was an exhibition of football down in Melbourne, where all football codes were invited to be apart of. Two NSWRL (now known as the NRL) clubs who partook in the event were the Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles and the Western Suburbs Magpies. Both clubs were from different spectrums, different landscapes in the Rugby League competition. The Sea Eagles from the Northern Pennisula of Sydney, whilst the Magpies were true to their name, based in Sydney’s West.
The legendary tale has it that Magpies Coach Roy Masters told his players that Manly did not want to fly on the same plane as the Western Suburbs players and refused to travel on the same bus. As to reasons why? Masters claimed that Manly administrators, officials and players alike looked down upon Western Suburbs, believing they were inferior beings from a second-rate region of Sydney’s metropolitan area.
This was enough tonic to infuriate the Magpies players who decided to take matters into their own hands when the two teams took the field as the exhibition of football. The result? Manly players were left bashed, bruised and bloodied. Spectators were left mortified and shocked at the spectacle. Roy Masters had created a monster; using a siege mentality. It’s us against them attitude which inspired his much maligned Western Suburbs team who lacked the class and talent of sides like Manly and Cronulla, but made up for it with sheer brutality and a ruthlessness that has never been witnessed in professional sport.
Masters would use motivational spiels to lift his players, citing that they were not good enough to play First Grade Rugby League in the eyes of their opponents; that they would never be successful on the field as well as off it; because they lived in ‘Fibro’ houses; were blue collar workers from the Western Suburbs, unlike their counterparts from affluent areas, who held good successful jobs who led comfortable lives. When his Magpie warriors would take the field, they would unleash hell, fueled by pure emotion that Masters had been able to implement into their psyche.
36 years on, the game has changed, rehabilitated itself from the thuggery and evolved to one of the most gladiatorial, physically testing sports on the planet. Professionalism is the name of the game these days. Rugby League is no longer just a sport, it’s a business, a product that is worth billions of dollars and governs billions in sponsorship and broadcasting rights. Footballers are no longer footballers. They are full-time athletes.
As such, the thought and memory of the infamous Fibros-Silvertails war and battles of yesteryear resurfacing in the modern day game would be laughed at right? Surely it would never happen in this political correct landscape and in a sport that is all about providing entertainment through its spectacular on field product of sinulating tries provided by its amazing athletes? Think again…
In 2007 a new fued was born, very much like the original, once again involving the Silvertails, Manly-Warringah. Whilst their combatants took the form of an interstate expansion club, in the Melbourne Storm. Be it through an inferiority complex, a mutual respect that went a little too far, or that a club, a team that many considered a waste of time would stand up and make their mark against one of the games successful clubs; that Manly had signed former Storm Halfback Matt Orford for overs, leaving the Victorian based franchise without a noted playmaker and leader leading into 2006. That the Storm had a rather Queensland Maroon flavour to its line up whilst Manly was well and truly decked out in NSW Blues players through its top 17 most weeks. Maybe it was all of the above that would see this modern day rivalry established (Or maybe it was just like everyone else, Melbourne hates Manly too)
Since 2007, Melbourne-Manly clashes have been something to savour. The games have been nothing short of epic. Fire, brimstone coupled by nail biting finishes at both Brookvale and down in Melbourne. Players have taken the field with the intent to punish their opposite number, their opponents, sending a message to one another who has the upper hand; who is the better player; who is the better team. Many a clash has resulted in injury and suspension to players on both sides of the rivalry. The pair have been engaged in three Golden Point thrillers since 2007. Have featured in two Grand Finals against one another, a qualifying final and a major semi final.
The bragging rights change from clash to clash quite consistently. 2007 saw Melbourne win the Premiership defeating Manly. 12 months late, Manly embarrassed the Storm by recording a record 40-0 result. In 2009, Melbourne knocked Manly out of the Finals. In 2011 Manly would go on to win the Premiership defeating New Zealand Warriors who has caused the upset of the year, defeating Melbourne, who were perhaps looking ahead to playing their nemesis a week later. In 2012, Melbourne would take great delight in ending the reigning Premiers 2012 title hopes by comprehensively putting the Silvertails to the sword in the Major Preliminary Final, where the Storm would be crowned Premiers that year.
The competitive rivalry has been alive and well since 2007, but it was not until 2011 where the built up angst, tension and (lets stop beating around the bush shall we?) HATRED, would rise to the fore. Just before halftime a fight broke out between the two sides which would see two players sin binned. Glen Stewart from Manly and Adam Blair for Melbourne who were supposedly sent temporarily from the field due to running in late and throwing a punch in the scuffle between both teams. On their way to their respective dressing sheds to cool off for 10 minutes, both players got to the sideline, exchanged what I’m sure were not kind and courteous pleasantries, stopped approached one another and let fly with a flurry of fists. This would see both teams charge towards Stewart and Blair who were going toe-to-toe like a Heavyweight bout before being swapped with Manly and Melbourne jerseys. The all in brawl would spill off the field onto the sideline, near cheerleaders and team mascots along with both sets of team benches.
Rugby League administrators saw it as a disgraceful act, referring to the incident as the black eye the game did not need, as the NRL was (as it still is today) trying to win the hearts and minds of kids and parents to play the sport. Both clubs were fined for the incident, which the media had touted as the ‘Battle of Brookvale’ whilst the players were dealt with a massive punishment. Stewart would not pull on the Maroon and White of Manly until Grand Final day, whilst Blair played his last game for the Storm, with Melbourne not being able to extend their season past their Major Preliminary Finals loss to the Warriors.
The animosity, detestation and bitterness between both clubs only intensified after this incident, which was eerily familiar. Scenes and images seen somewhat 36 years ago down in Melbourne at an exhibition of football, Lidcombe Oval and the birthplace of the most recent warfare, Brookvale Oval. Whilst both clubs do not engage in a traditional ‘softening up period’ that used to take place in the 70’s and early 80’s, between the Sea Eagles and Magpies, Melbourne and Manly’s substitute is simply close, physical encounters that more often than not, leave fans on the edge of their seat.
Whilst there are many a derby in Rugby League like the Brisbane-North Queensland or South Sydney-Eastern Suburbs (Sydney Roosters) which in their own right have established their own respective rivalry, the enmity and rancor that exists between Melbourne and Manly is unique and differs significantly to these traditional rivalries. Even when the current crop of players from both the Sea Eagles and Storm have hung up the boots, one can surely bet that the rivalry will be spoken about and live on through the next generation of player from both clubs.
A player who can atest to this, is fan favourite, George Rose, having now called both Brookvale and AAMI Park home. Rose knows all to well how hard, tight and firey these clashes have developed into, featuring in many a contest whilst wearing the Maroon and White, but has since traded those colours for Purple. Rose gave insight at a recent Storm media conference “I know how much the Storm game means to Manly every year. It’s always earmarked on the calendar and always a game they get up for. I’m expecting a very tough game from them. It’s something that brings out the best game for the season with both teams”
Although many from both camps state that the rivalry is nothing more than mutual respect, internally that is a standard cliché to downplay the actual hatred and aversion that exists and has established the modern day Fibros-Silvertails of the 21st century. And whilst Melbourne are not a fledging working class Rugby League Club from the Western Suburbs, they draw similar ‘underdog’ type synergy being in a State with a different landscape. One cannot help but see that Melbourne are the Fibros in this latest rivalry, simply because everyone loves to “hate Manly”.
Written by: @DWATSONHAYES